What happened between Homefront‘s first and second seasons?

 

Nearly every television series undergoes major or minor tweaks in between seasons (introducing new cast members, sets, ongoing plots, etc.) in order to keep the show fresh.  Considering that Homefront was renewed for a second season only by the skin of its teeth, it seems probable that the series’ writers/producers felt great pressure – either from ABC or from themselves – to make substantial changes that might improve its ratings during its second season.  Below is some speculation on decisions made between Homefront’s first and second seasons.

 

·        Did the writers/producers not know that Homefront was renewed for a second season until after the first-season finale aired?  Given that the first season’s final episode aired while Dear Abby’s and TV Guide’s campaigns to save the series were still in overdrive, it seems likely that the season ender was written in part as a possible series finale in the event Homefront were cancelled.  After all, just like the real series finale (“All Good Things”) at the end of the second season, this episode (“Songs Unsung Are The Sweetest”) features a lot of big decisions and happy resolutions (Anne and Al marry, Charlie leaves Caroline, the Davises finally open their restaurant, Hank seems to be making peace with himself) and a few provocative loose ends (Will Jeff and Ginger be able to wait until they’re married?  Will Charlie choose Judy or Gina?) just in case the show returns.  And like “All Good Things,” this episode features scenes and themes that echo the pilot episode, including Jeff and Hank (in uniform) returning to Kirtland Hill for another dramatic confrontation and the reopening of Rupert’s, which Hank learned had closed in “S.N.A.F.U.”

 

·        Out with the old and in with youth?  In a 1993 interview, Mimi Kennedy claimed that a “partly network-inspired, partly producer-initiated” decision was made to emphasize the younger cast members during the second season.  This might have seemed a logical step for survival, as other prime-time soap opera-style series such as 90210 and Melrose Place were currently enjoying huge successes with the same formula.  But many of the second season’s major storylines (the birth of Anne and Al’s child, Gloria’s crisis of faith, Mike’s flirtations with infidelity, Anne’s polio, the “Red Scare”) don’t necessarily reflect that such a shift actually took place.

 

·        Was the decision not made to make Judy a full-fledged cast member until the summer?  True, Judy had already appeared in the final four episodes of the first season, but she had not yet been featured in the opening credits along with the other regular cast.  Moreover, the writers don’t seem to know just what to do with her during these four episodes besides provide commentary on the actions and dialogue of the other characters.  She isn’t given her own storylines until the second season.

 

·        Was the decision to write out Hank made only after the first season had ended?  The first season’s final episode seems to leave Hank’s fate open-ended, and his last-minute attitude adjustment suggests that his character was at last on the upswing.  While Lynn Marie Latham claimed Hank was written out because “we didn’t seem to generate…many stories for Hank,” many Homefront egroup members have suggested Hank and Judy could have become romantically involved.  This makes some sense, as Judy’s arrival coincided with Sarah’s departure, and Judy and Hank may have found solace in each other as widowers (Homefront egroup Apr. 19, 2003).

 

·        Was the decision to write out Robert not made until the second season began?  The writers/producers could have easily used Robert’s departure for France in the final episode of Season One as an excuse for the character’s permanent exit.  In the same way that Hank’s disappearance was conveniently explained at the beginning of the second season by Anne’s comment that “Hank is in Chicago and happier than he’s been in months,” the writers could have had Abe and Gloria explain that Robert had found Perette and had decided to remain in France.  Instead, Robert returns with Perette in the second season for three uneasy episodes before they both disappear for good.

 

 

Home